Runways seem to be fine, although whole airport is a huge mess of convoluted and illegal taxiways and other assets. Needs to be erazed and redone eventually.
This scenery pack seems to have the airport location shifted 50m - 100m too far to the west, and also slightly to the south. The error is not consistent across the airport - runway 06R seems less inaccurate than runway 06L. The errors make it impossible to fly an ILS approach to this airport, even though the nav-aids are in the correct locations.
This conclusion based upon a precise comparison of localiser and glideslope locations in GoogleEarth, and also by comparing X-Plane's road network to airport features.
GeorgeSpartan
commented
in reference to scenery pack
86908on September 4, 2023 1:29 PM
This airport has had major modifications since the last release. New JC taxiway, new taxiways/taxiway names between 06L/24R & B. Most taxiways will be renamed soon in November. Runway 28 will become taxiway C and will officially close after 5 years. Someone stay up to date with the changes please :D
Runway 06L not aligned in ILS
Robin Peel April 28, 2018 9:11 PM
I re-aligned and corrected the positions of all the ILS components at CYUL. This will be in the next ILS data release.
runways 06L and 06R are off-center.
Cessna 172.
Michael Minnhaar April 24, 2018 8:59 PM
Can you be more specific what you mean with off-center ?
The runways position in the existing scenery file ? Relative to what ?
What does the mention of the aircraft type mean ?
Jan Vogel March 28, 2021 2:37 PM
Runways seem to be fine, although whole airport is a huge mess of convoluted and illegal taxiways and other assets. Needs to be erazed and redone eventually.
This scenery pack seems to have the airport location shifted 50m - 100m too far to the west, and also slightly to the south. The error is not consistent across the airport - runway 06R seems less inaccurate than runway 06L. The errors make it impossible to fly an ILS approach to this airport, even though the nav-aids are in the correct locations.
This conclusion based upon a precise comparison of localiser and glideslope locations in GoogleEarth, and also by comparing X-Plane's road network to airport features.
bkeith April 30, 2018 8:31 AM
Fix in progress based on WED 1.7
Julian Lockwood April 30, 2018 9:45 PM
Closing this, as a fix is imminent.
This airport has had major modifications since the last release. New JC taxiway, new taxiways/taxiway names between 06L/24R & B. Most taxiways will be renamed soon in November. Runway 28 will become taxiway C and will officially close after 5 years. Someone stay up to date with the changes please :D
CYUL runway 10-28 was decommissioned some time ago, the scenery should show a taxiway in its place.
ollie April 12, 2024 5:16 AM
Resolved in 101802 from a visual perspective, will need to be deleted from the scenery once x-plane CIFP data catches up accordingly.